Recurring Deposit or Debt Mutual Funds: A Comparative Guide

Debt Mutual Funds and Recurring Deposits are two investment options that can be used to develop wealth. Both are low-risk investments that permit the long-term investment of modest sums of money. However, there are distinguishing characteristics between them.

This article provides a comprehensive comparison of Recurring Deposits and Debt Mutual Funds to assist investors in making well-informed decisions based on their financial goals.

Table of Contents

Understanding Debt Mutual Fund

Mutual funds that invest primarily in debt securities are known as “Debt Mutual Funds.” Typically managed by a professional fund manager, their investment objective is to generate capital gains through the acquisition of debt instruments. Debt funds are similar to mutual funds in that they aggregate money from numerous investors and make investments with the goal of increasing wealth over time. The primary difference between these funds and mutual funds is that they invest primarily in debt instruments (debt securities). Mutual funds typically invest in equities or other types of securities, whereas debt funds typically invest in bonds and other types of securities.

If you are an investor seeking a safe method to invest in debt securities, a debt fund may be the best option for you. The concept behind these funds is straightforward: purchase a portfolio of debt securities with built-in liquidity. This means that investors can sell their shares anytime without incurring a loss if the investment is not performing as expected. Since the value of each security is unknown at the time of purchase, investing in debt mutual funds entails less risk than investing in individual companies directly.

Investment Risks in Debt Funds

1) Low Profits – Debt funds in India offer 5-8% annual returns. However, the rate of return is lower than that of mutual funds and insurance funds. This means that investors who choose debt funds will have to wait longer for their money to compound and expand.

2) Not Totally Secure – Debt funds are not completely secure from the associated risks. Due to the fact that lenders typically charge interest rates that are higher than what they receive from savings account deposits, the risk of default is high. This means that if the creditor defaults on the loan, there is no assurance that you will receive your money in full.

3) Not for the long term – When considering long-term investments, it is preferable to consider alternatives such as mutual funds or insurance companies, which offer higher rates of return and lower risk than debt funds.

Understanding Recurring Deposit

A recurring deposit account is a fixed-term deposit with a fixed interest rate. They are used to provide regular income and to invest in financial markets over the long term. Recurring deposits are essentially recurring deposits made with a personal bank account or other financial institutions, such as credit cards or insurance companies. People who have a fixed sum of money each month (or, in some cases, each week) that they can put towards debt repayment without having to worry about interest rates or maturity dates use these deposits.

The primary benefit is that you can invest your money over an extended period of time and still earn the same amount of interest as you would with an immediate investment.

RD permits you to earn specified interest at regular intervals on the amount invested until the investment matures or a predetermined term expires. After the maturity period concludes, the total amount (invested principal plus accrued interest) is paid to the investor.

Investment Risks in Recurring Deposits

1) No Early withdrawal of money – The first disadvantage is that you cannot withdraw the funds at any time. Before withdrawing the funds, you must wait for a specified period of time.

2) The monthly investment amount cannot be changed – The second disadvantage is that once the monthly investment amount has been determined, it cannot be changed. Recurring deposits have a fixed amount, so once the investment amount has been determined, it cannot be altered.

3) Comparatively lower interest rate – Recurring deposits have a lower interest rate than ordinary bank accounts. This account has a lower interest rate than other categories of investment accounts. If you desire higher portfolio interest rates, then this may not be for you.

Nonetheless, you can use the Recurring Deposit Calculator to estimate returns. You can calculate potential returns by entering monthly investments, interest rates, and time periods into the calculator’s designated fields. Within a fraction of a second, the result will be provided.

A Comparison Between Recurring Deposit Vs Debt Mutual Funds

Individuals, organisations, and governments use debt funds as a form of investment to finance debt. These investments are made with bank or other creditor-loaned funds.

Similar to debt funds, recurring deposits enable you to borrow money on credit terms at a fixed interest rate for a specified time period.

Due to their guaranteed returns, RDs have a low-risk profile, whereas DMFs bear a moderate risk depending on the underlying securities and interest rate movements.

Returns: RDs offer fixed returns for the duration, whereas DMFs offer variable returns dependent on the performance of the underlying debt securities.
Liquidity: RDs may penalise imprudent withdrawals, thereby increasing the liquidity and accessibility of DMFs.
Taxation: The interest earned on RDs is entirely taxable, while DMFs provide indexation benefits on long-term capital gains, resulting in a lower tax liability.

The Takeaway – Both are necessary for the health of your portfolio. Keep the RD for essential expenses and currency that can be withdrawn in the event of an emergency. Invest in debt mutual funds for everything else, but keep a watch on your bank balance to ensure you have sufficient liquid funds to cover any unforeseen expenses. Recurring Deposits may be the best option for investors who are risk-averse and desire guaranteed returns and disciplined savings. Debt Mutual Funds, on the other hand, are a viable option for investors pursuing potentially higher returns and willing to accept moderate market risk. Ultimately, only you will know what will work best for your financial situation, so choose the option with which you are most comfortable.

You may also read the following posts;